I think I must be the only person in the universe who enjoyed this film. But then I am a huge Shahid fan and have the ability to shut out everything else that's happening apart from him, so perhaps that's why. Although I liked Amrita Rao here too. Everyone else, not so much!I agree it's not a great story and the end is dire, but there are lots of pretty moments along the way. I have actually watched it more than once, (although mainly for the songs) and I have to say that sadly, it's not the worst film Shahid has made! :)
You're by no means the only one who enjoyed it, and even I wanted to It just seems that whether they speak shuddh Hindi, Urdu, or English, filmi people have no grasp of the word "edit"
I enjoyed the film because of the same reason Heather mentioned - Shahid. And Amrita, though she wasn't particularly good in this one. Of course it was extremely sugary and traditional, so it's not one of my favourites... but I found it okay for a one-time watch. Actually I liked it better than HAHK, hated that one (sorry ;)).
Thanks so much for stopping by, Mette, and NEVER feel like you ought to apologise for your personal tastes in film. Especially when you see so many more of them and write about them so much better than I :)